Sep 22, 2014
Home| Tools| Events| Blogs| Discussions Sign UpLogin

In the Shop

RSS By: Dan Anderson, Farm Journal

As a farm machinery mechanic and writer, Dan brings a hands-on approach that only a pro can muster. Along with his In the Shop blog, Dan writes a column by the same name as well as the Shop Series for Farm Journal magazine. Always providing practical information, he is a master at tackling technical topics and making them easy for all of our readers to understand. He and his wife, Becky, live near Bouton, Iowa.

The Temptations of a Tool Tightwad

Jan 11, 2009
 I am drawn to cheap tools as a moth is drawn to a flame. Sometimes I get bargains, tools that perform well for a low price, and sometimes I waste my money on junk that is essentially chromed scrap metal.

For example, I'm happy and proud of the $15 mega-punches I bought through Northern Tool and Supply. Similar punches and pin drivers from Snap-on and Mac were in the $40 to $50 range. The first few times I used those 20-inch long punches with 3/8-inch and 1/2-inch tips I flinched in fear they'd shatter like glass. But they've proven durable and I now hammer on them with impunity.

I wasn't so lucky with a discount store set of screwdrivers. I hoped I could pick up a set of flat- and Phillips-head screwdrivers for use in the toolbox in my garage at home for $15, compared to, say, a $40 Klein-brand set of pro-quality screwdrivers. It only took a few stubborn Phillips-head screws to chew up the heads of the discount store screwdrivers, and I'm not very confident of the durability of the accompanying flat-blade drivers. I should have opted for the Kleins or an equivalent-quality set of screwdrivers.

A farmer -friend recently asked what sort of torque wrench he should buy for his farm shop. We discussed the various types of clicker torque wrenches and thei advantages/disadvantages of each style. Then it came to prices. I've got a discount tool catalog on my desk that offers a 1/2-inch drive clicker-style torque wrench for $19.99. Sears' online tool catalog lists their Craftsman 1/2-inch drive clicker torque wrench for $79.99, and an SK-brand micro-tooth, pro-quality 1/2-inch drive clicker for $291.00. We agreed that the $19.99 wrench was suspect, but that the $291 wrench was more than he needed for the occasional jobs he'd use it for. On the other hand, for $19.99 it might be worth trying the cheapest wrench--it might work fine for occasional duty in a farm shop, though I'm suspicious of how accurate it might be, let alone how durable.

The same goes for the $9.99 air impact hammer set that's advertised in a mail-order catalog I got last week. $9.99 for an air impact hammer including 5, "heavy duty chrome moly chisels"...?  Folks, I paid more than $200 for the Snap-on air hammer I use at the dealership, and around $3 each for chisel bits. I'm just a little leery of the $9.99 tool--though it would be interesting to buy one and unleash it on some stubborn roll pins, just to see what would happen. I'd want to have on a good pair of safety glasses and thick leather gloves, however...

I'll continue to succumb to the temptation of cheapie tools. Every so often I end up with tools that truly are a bargain, with performance in excess of their cost. I'm also sure that the junk drawer in my tool box will continue to gain examples from the other end of the tool-quality spectrum, the ones that proved to be exactly as cheap as their price.
Log In or Sign Up to comment

COMMENTS (4 Comments)

Matt Feucht
You get what you pay for is right on.
9:37 PM Jan 25th
I try to keep high grade tools in the shop and the cheapies in the tool boxes I use in the field. I can lose a $25 crescent wrench just as fast as a $5 one!
10:17 AM Jan 13th
The Home Page of Agriculture
© 2014 Farm Journal, Inc. All Rights Reserved|Web site design and development by|Site Map|Privacy Policy|Terms & Conditions