advertisement

Sunday, February 25, 2007
 
Farm economics from the Dept. of Commerce...

One of my gripes with the USDA is it fails to put farm economic figures in context with either the nation or the globe. My experience is most farmers have wildly inflated ideas of their contribution to their local and national economies.

Here's how to find out for yourself. Click here for county level income numbers. (How the people in your county earn a living)
  1. Click on CA05 - Personal income and detailed earnings by industry
  2. Choose NAICS data for the most recent. The BEA switched industry categories a few years ago - this is the new list.
  3. Pick a state, click next.
  4. Pick a county (or the whole state) and year (s), hit "Display"
Line 81 is farm earnings. Compare that with total earnings (line 10). Also compare with line 47. Transfer payments are mostly SS checks, Medicaid, federal pensions, etc.

In almost all rural counties I have looked up transfer payments are 3-10 times higher than farm earnings.

I was personally stunned when I first looked up Edgar County, IL. It's covered with farms and has no big city, and yet farms contribute only about 8% of the local income. Meanwhile, transfer payments bring in 21%.

My conclusion: to save rural America, save Social Security.

Many producers like to argue that just means farmers aren't getting paid enough, but crimony - how high would prices have to get to move it up much? For example, in IL farms contribute all of 0.4% of the Gross State Product.

Some also say we should judge by gross income (sales), but then you would have to judge other industries the same way. Besides, why are we so proud of how little we keep of the dollars that flow through our farms? The BEA sets the rules for measuring economic clout, and it uses your schedule F. Farmers can't play the game AND referee too, ya know.

Illinois is not about farms. Neither is IA, IN, ND, SD, MN, CA, NJ, etc. Look it up for yourself.

As a rule farmers are upset when I share these numbers. I have been accused of "talking down" farmers. If the facts are disrespectful to our image of ourselves, my assertion is the problem is with our self-image.

We don't have be the center of attention to be a vital part of a community or state economy. In fact, when we stop insisting it's all about us, we improve our chances of being truly happy.

Labels:

 
Comments:
Interesting points. Based on a fast visit to the Edgar County link, I'd guess that farm program payments also fall into the "transfer payments" category.

You don't mention the "multiplier effect"--that somehow one dollar earned on the farm generates X dollars of economic activity in the county. It makes sense to me, though I'm no economist. And wouldn't a dollar of Social Security also have a multiplier effect?
 
bill: This data is derived from income tax info, so farm payments are already included in farm income. To really see the stuff for your county, run through the first link.

As for the multiplier effect, please check for later post.
 
Intersting read. The U if Illinios did a study that found that Sch F can misrepresent farm income by as much as 80%. As I recall the descrepancy was a result of Sec 179/Depreciation and the lack of an accrual basis used to report income. Thoughts??
 
John:

I'm surprised it isn't higher than that (80%). Cash accounting allows us to postpone, but not avoid taxes by increasing inventories and prepaying expenses. I am ambivalent on the merit of this idea, and am too lazy to switch to accrual.

But it all comes home to roost. You end up in a year with all income and no expenses. My guess is this happens about age 59.

Still as a close friend once pointed out, "After you pay your taxes, you get to keep all the rest!"
 
Post a Comment



<< Home
US Farm Report host John Phipps surfs the Web so you don't have to...

 My Photo
Name: John Phipps
Location: Chrisman, Illinois, United States

Jan and I farm 1700 acres near Chrisman, IL. I have also written humor and commentary for Farm Journal and Top Producer for 13 years. Please visit my website (www.johnwphipps.com) to learn about my speaking services for your group's next meeting.

ARCHIVES
April 2006 / May 2006 / June 2006 / July 2006 / August 2006 / September 2006 / October 2006 / November 2006 / December 2006 / January 2007 / February 2007 / March 2007 / April 2007 / May 2007 / June 2007 / July 2007 /


advertisement

MORE FROM JOHN
On the Coffee Table
What's for Dinner

Farm JournalTop ProducerBeef TodayDairy TodayAgDay
U.S. Farm ReportPro FarmerPro Farmer Members

AgWeb Professional - Subscription InformationAdd AgWeb.com to your Favorites

FAQContact UsPrivacy PolicyAdvertise on AgWeb.com

Quotes by eSignal • Quotes delayed at least 10 min

© Copyright 2006 AgWeb.com a division of Farm Journal, Inc.

Home    |    Agriculture News    |    Weather    |    Money & Markets    |    Ag Discussions    |    Site Map