Milk prices aren’t the prime attraction for moving to a new area
The heartland between the Rockies and the Mississippi River appears to offer the most dairy-friendly resources and long-term future for those looking to build new or satellite dairies.
That was not only the professional assessment of a dairy relocation consultant but the personal experience of three dairy producers who spoke at the Dairy Today Elite Producer Business Conference in Las Vegas this past November.
Dairy relocation consultant Tom Haren and dairy producers Linda Hodorff, Rein Landman and Mike McCarty comprised a panel that discussed, "Where Will You Build Your Next Dairy?"
Social, financial and regulatory pressures are squeezing many dairies and forcing some to look outside their long-time operating zones. That was the case for Landman, who moved from the Netherlands to South Dakota in 2003. He and his family built a new dairy along the I-29 corridor of eastern South Dakota. Today, their Linde Dairy milks 1,200 cows. "It’s home now," Landman said.
Since Landman’s relocation, several cheese plants have been built along I-29. "Plants are competing for milk, there’s the potential to milk more cows and it’s easy working with our neighbors," he told the crowd. "It’s a win-win."
Local milk prices aren’t the prime attraction for moving to a new dairy area, Haren said. What is increasingly important is the availability of feed and stability of operating conditions for the next 20 to 25 years.
"Producers are going to put facilities where they have the most control," said Haren, whose AGPROfessionals company provides regulatory consulting, resource planning and engineering for agriculture. "As dairies continue to consolidate, your decision will be driven by where you can operate best financially. That’s away from population centers."
The right location for a new dairy requires research, planning and proximity to feed.
That was a key driver for Linda Hodorff. She and her, husband, Doug, and the Hodorff family have retained their Eden, Wis., dairy while Linda and Doug added their own satellite dairy near Milburn, Neb. Attracted by the availability of feed, Linda and Doug first invested in their own heifer facility in Nebraska in 1999. In 2005, "we saw additional opportunities and bought a dairy in central Nebraska," she said.
The couple’s time is now split between Wisconsin, where the family milks 950 cows, and their own Broken Bow Dairy in Nebraska. Linda and Doug plan to increase their 600-cow Nebraska herd to the same size as the Wisconsin facility.
The Hodorffs have already expanded their Nebraska dairy’s original milking parlor into an expandable double-16 configuration. The couple also recently added a nonfamily junior partner, Jake Stern. Linda said that an ag-friendly community and the availability of feed are key factors to dairy relocations.
Mike McCarty told the audience about his family’s relocation from Pennsylvania to Kansas. He, his parents and three brothers faced a climate in Pennsylvania that was becoming unfriendly to agriculture, making it impossible to expand the dairy. "If we wanted to survive another 100 years, we knew it had to be somewhere else," he said.
Rein Landman chose South Dakota for his new dairy when he moved to the U.S. from the Netherlands in 2003.
The move to Kansas, which took five years of planning, has been successful for the McCartys, who now operate three dairies there. They have also formed a partnership with Dannon and are involved in a processing plant on one of their dairies.
"There are a lot of things right about Kansas," McCarty said. He pointed to the state’s tax incentives, permitting ease, the ag-friendly community, the wide open spaces and weather that suits cow production. He also emphasizes the importance of careful planning before building or buying a dairy elsewhere.
"Be patient, do your homework and spend time in that community prior to moving there," McCarty said.
If you asked 105 dairy producers what they consider the most important factor in deciding where to operate a dairy, they’d tell you it’s availability of land for feed production.
At least, that’s what University of Minnesota’s Marin Bozic discovered when he surveyed attendees at Dairy Today’s Elite Producer Business Conference in November. According to the results of the written surveys, the 105 respondents farm an average of 2,581 acres, milk 3,631 cows and count 2,747 heifers in their operations.
Here’s how the group rated factors for choosing an area for dairying. The top five were ranked as "important" or "critically important" to 90% or more of the
1. Availability of land for feed production
2. Cost of feed
3. Supply of locally grown forages
4. Availability of land for animal waste
5. Availability of water
6. Availability of land for construction
7. Complexity of state and local laws for waste
8. Mailbox milk price
9. State and local perception of animal agriculture
10. Average temperature
11. Proximity to milk processors
12. Cost of financing
13. Cost of hauling milk
14. Number of milk processors
15. Proximity to family
16. Average precipitation
17. Construction cost of new facilities
18. Local population density
19. Cost of labor
20. Proximity to a large fluid market
21. Average cost of living
22. Existence of economic incentives
23. Absence of a Federal Milk Marketing Order
24. Proximity to custom heifer growers
25. Heifer availability
The survey participants were evenly divided on when they had last relocated: 49% said that it had been 10 years of less, while 49% said it had been longer than 10 years.