Are Soybeans Overpriced?

February 13, 2019 02:23 PM
According to AgriTalk host Chip Flory most analysts say they are, including Dr. Frayne Olson, professor of agribusiness and applied economics at North Dakota State University.

Despite all of the rumors surrounding the on again, off again trade meeting of President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping, new crop soybean contracts broke $9.50 Wednesday. Are they overvalued? According to AgriTalk host Chip Flory most analysts say they are, including Dr. Frayne Olson, professor of agribusiness and applied economics at North Dakota State University.

“When I try and do the numbers backwards and say, well, if you look at the November contract, what is the implication for planted acreage? What are the implications for U.S. production, I can't quite get the numbers to work,” he told Flory on AgriTalk. “I think what's happening, my opinion again, is that we have some optimism built in. I think there's a little bit of a risk premium that's built into this this market because of not only some of the conditions weather-wise in Brazil and, you know, most expectations are that Brazilian crop is getting smaller. But then also I think there's expectations that we're looking positive with a trade deal.”

He added there’s a phycological battle going on. Despite the possibility for a solid trade deal with China, Olson said the damage has already been done.

“We've seen a massive shift in basis levels again, that's all because of the transportation issues. About 75% of the beans grown in North Dakota get shipped to the PNW ports, about 98% of those get on a boat and ended up in China,” he explained. “So, we were and still are literally on the front lines of the soybean trade issues.”

While he does believe China will start buying U.S. soybeans again, he predicts they won’t ever buy at the levels they have in the past.

“In my view, there's already been a fundamental shift and we're trying to figure out what this new path of the soybean market is going to look like,” he said. “I do think also how that path plays out will be heavily impacted by these trade negotiations, and if there's some kind of requirement that the Chinese purchase U.S. soybeans or whether the Chinese are given flexibility to purchase from who they want to. There's still a lot of moving parts.”

U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer is in Beijing this week for trade talks. While White House officials previously indicated the two presidents would not meet prior to their March 1 trade deadline, on Wednesday a USDA official said the two will meet at some point in March.

Back to news


Spell Check

Montfort, WI
2/14/2019 08:05 AM

  Did anyone see the comment that the previous export business we did we will not get back? That is what demand destruction looks like. I have been hammering this for 6 months. Anyone who believes otherwise thinks the word denial is a river in Egypt.

Jonesboro , AR
2/14/2019 07:13 AM

  Hey Neil, get me an address and I'll send that MFP money right to you! Freaking dumba$$ lol!

Neil Dusseault
Boerne, TX
2/14/2019 04:00 AM

  Soybeans were among the first commodities I traded in the futures market 19 years ago. The price range was $4 to $5/bushel. Also, Trump provided Soybean farmers with a multi-billion bailout at taxpayers expense. Prices have come up by about $1/bushel since then, and Soybean prices are typically lower at this time of year anyway. So, once the Summer arrives, Soybeans will at least be trading within normal territory, therefore all taxpayer bailouts should be returned then.


Corn College TV Education Series


Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!


Market Data provided by
Brought to you by Beyer