Chip Flory: It's Not Cliche If It Works

November 28, 2017 10:33 AM
Chip Flory

Marketing clichés are as hum-drum as a drawn-out harvest season. But in nearly all clichés is a nugget of wisdom, and if the saying represents a concept—especially if it’s timely—it deserves our respect and consideration. With that in mind, let’s string a few base hits together and build a marketing plan for 2018/19 corn, soybeans and wheat.

Yes, this is about 2018-crop marketings. There is still work to do on 2017-crop sales and the concepts discussed here also apply to old-crop sales, but sometimes conditions demand a longer view. Now is one of those times.

Carryover is commonly referred to as “the bottom line” of a marketing year. But the bottom line of one marketing year is a top-line, supply-side entry into the next year as beginning stocks. In the November Supply & Demand Report from USDA, the 2018/19 beginning stocks were estimated at 2.49 billion bushels for corn, 425 million bushels for soybeans and 935 million bushels for wheat. There are still nine months for adjustments to these estimates, but only wheat is expected to see a year-to-year decline in beginning stocks.

Big stocks of grains and oilseeds carried into a new-crop marketing year mean it will take a severe yield cut to support higher prices. Tight stocks make markets more vulnerable to even minor yield nicks.

Let’s assume no year-to-year changes to harvested acres for the three major crops in the year ahead. At 83.1 million harvested corn acres, the 2.49 billion bushels of beginning stocks represent nearly 30 bu. per acre. With harvested soybean acres of 89.5 million, the 425 million bushels represent 4.75 bu. per acre. Wheat beginning stocks of 935 million bushels at 37.6 million harvested acres represent 24.9 bu. per acre. Beginning stocks give the 2018 corn, soybean and wheat crops a sizeable head start in meeting total demand in the 2018/19 marketing year.

Obviously, it doesn’t take zero beginning stocks to be price-bullish. The price outlook for 2018/19 would be much more optimistic if corn beginning stocks were a billion bushels smaller, and taking 150 million bushels off the beginning point for soybeans and 200 million bushels off for wheat would brighten the price outlook. So, realistically, the 2018/19 supply-side cushions are about 12 bu. per acre for corn, 1.7 bu. per acre on soybeans and 5.3 bu. per acre for wheat. Threaten the markets with 2018 yield losses at those levels, and prices will work to the upside. If act-ual 2018 yields are that much below trendline projections, the supply-side cushion for the 2019/20 marketing year would be thin enough to keep 2018 post-harvest prices at profitable levels until markets are comfortable with 2019-crop potential.

When farmers string together years of trendline or better yields, beginning stocks build until it’s difficult to start a downtrend in stocks to support an uptrend in prices. It’s the snowball effect. Beginning stocks become so large it requires a big drop in harvested acres or a significant yield cut to start inching stocks lower.

Unfortunately, the snowball seems to be rolling downhill for corn and soybeans.

Corn beginning stocks in 2015/16 were slightly more than 1.7 billion bushels, which was the last time the national average on-farm cash price was above $3.50. The snowball started the 2016/17 marketing year at the top of the hill with beginning stocks nearly steady, but prices slipped to an average of $3.36 as 2017/18 beginning stocks built to nearly 2.3 billion bushels. Now, beginning stocks are projected to keep building into 2018/19 to nearly 2.5 billion bushels.

Soybean beginning stocks were extremely tight in 2014/15 at less than 100 million bushels. The snowball effect started in 2015/16 as beginning stocks doubled and leveled off at just less than 200 million bushels. It regained momentum to 301 million bushels in 2017/18. Beginning stocks are projected to roll up to 425 million bushels for 2018/19.

That’s the kind of long-range view required in a market with adequate to surplus supplies. Consider this question: What would create enough supply-side uncertainty to support prices? The answer is thinning the supply-side cushion with production cuts or a major increase in demand.

Snowballing beginning stocks make it difficult for markets to sustain a rally to raise prices to consistently profitable levels, but they don’t eliminate the possibility of a rally. When rallies happen in current market conditions, they will likely be hard-fought and short-lived, but there will be price bumps. If you’re prepared, they will provide an opportunity to “hit singles” on old- and new-crop marketings.

Book small profits when available on relatively small percentages of bushels in the bin and bushels you expect to produce in 2018. This approach means using several marketing events throughout the risk-management period, rather than a few large sales at clearly profitable levels. You’re hitting singles instead of home runs—and that’s OK.

Consider the following steps to a disciplined yet flexible approach to marketing grain:   

  • Set price targets at your cash-market hubs that will automatically trigger sales when those targets are hit and have the discipline to allow those targets to be hit. That’s the most efficient way to grab pricing opportunities likely available for just short periods of time.
  • Layer sales targets above your first target that will sell into price strength while building returns.
  • Have a trailing target under the market that will increase sales before prices fall back below break-even levels. Each target should sell between 5% and 10% of what’s in the bin or what you expect to produce in the year ahead.
  • If yield risks develop or usage outpaces expectations and price gains build momentum, cover the opportunity risk with either a long call option or long futures position to reopen upside price potential.
Back to news


Spell Check

Eaton, OH
11/29/2017 06:49 AM

  Great job on article. Good read. My mother’s maiden name is Flory, we are probably related.


Related News

Corn College TV Education Series


Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!


Market Data provided by
Brought to you by Beyer