Fortune Magazine Investigates Climate Change 'Paradox'

July 6, 2016 12:00 PM

Is climate change real, and is it caused or influenced by human activity? This is one of the great debates of our time – one that has been banged up, tossed around and argued passionately for years.

One curiosity of the debate is that consumers and scientists are at odds over the existence and causes of climate change. A recent Pew Research Center poll suggests scientists are 37% more likely than consumers to believe climate change is caused by human activity, for example.

That gap is also prevalent within the farming community. In a December 2015 poll, 78% of farmers said climate change wasn’t even a threat to be taken seriously.

Beth Kowitt, a writer with Fortune Magazine, has noticed what she calls a “paradox” with American farmers and climate change.  

“Farmers are perhaps the segment of the population most affected by climate change, and yet a significant number of them don’t believe in it—especially the notion that it’s man-made,” she writes.

Kowitt says she picked up on this phenomenon on a recent feature she wrote that put her on “the receiving end of a lot of eye rolls” whenever she brought up climate change.

She blames, in part, the politicization of the issue, quoting Yale Law School professor Dan Kahan, who has observed that people tend to selectively credit or dismiss evidence presented to them when presented with “culturally disputed” facts. The result over time is increasingly polarized views of these hot-button issues. Think GMOs, vaccinations and yes, climate change.

About farmers specifically, Kahan notes, “[They] are simultaneously the most skeptical when it comes to climate change, but the group that uses climate science in decision-making the most.”

Kowitt argues is that it probably doesn’t even matter if farmers believe in climate change or not. You can read how she came to that conclusion here.

Meantime, where do you fit into the climate change debate? Is it naturally occurring or manmade? Real danger or political puff? Fact or fiction? Weigh in with a  comment below.

Back to news



Spell Check

Robert Fearnow
Tipton, IN
10/22/2016 06:05 PM

  Farmers are and have always deal with weather/ climate extremes. It is a way of life. Some of the worst weather has happened in the distant past as well as present time. The difference is our education systen has promoted the idea that climate change is a problem. Go to your School and check it out. I have been in agriculture all my life. I am 72 years old and my Father was born in 1896. He was a farmer and my Grandfather was a farmer. Guess what the had to deal with extreme weather way back then. Guess what they weren't using fossil fuel but the weather was still extreme. I am convinced that climate change is man made. Man MADE UP and taught in School to form an agenda for taxing and minipulating business and people. I see the young people accept this way of thinking because it is what the have learned in class. We need to stop being lead around by the all knowing world leaders. THINK OUT SIDE OF THE CLIMATE CHANGE BOX.

Tucson, AZ
7/3/2016 11:19 AM

  Yes - I believe global warming is occurring. I do not believe that it is caused by humans nor can humans do anything about it. I maintain that if all humans were to die today, the global warming problem would not improve but continue on its path until nature allows it to reach the top, at which time, the earth will begin cooling.

Bruce Jackson
Lockesburg , AR
7/4/2016 12:46 PM

  Is climate change real ; Yes ; Is it manmade no ; we are influencing probably but look at long term history before man . Along with that our air and water is so much cleaner in all of North America and Europe than 50 years ago.


Corn College TV Education Series


Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!


Market Data provided by
Brought to you by Beyer