Gulke: USDA’s Yield Estimates for Corn, Soybeans ‘Really a Shocker’

August 12, 2015 04:00 PM
cc michigan 2015

If you were taken aback Wednesday by USDA’s decision to raise yield estimates for corn to 168.8 bu. and soybeans to 46.9 bu., you’re in good company.

“If they just looked at the plant population and didn’t touch the corn cobs and didn’t look at anything else to see whether it’s going to make it or not, then I could see this,” said Jerry Gulke, president of the Gulke Group in Chicago, in a special report with Farm Journal Radio. “Based on plant count and cob count, it doesn’t look that bad, but boy, you start stripping stuff back in the Eastern Corn Belt,” and the assessment of the crop’s potential changes dramatically. “I’m even on the side of thinking, ‘Do they really know what they are doing or don’t they?’” he said. “Even in my own crop in Northern Illinois yesterday, we found some Northern leaf blight that really got us in the last two weeks. Wow--our yield dropped 25 bushels an acre at least.”

The higher forecast for soybean yield also surprised him.

“This is really a shocker,” he said. “At almost 47 bushels an acre, that is going to be an unbelievable yield considering what I’ve seen out there and the August weather.”

Gulke added: "If one considers that the good-to-excellent this year is 7% less than a year ago and a yield predicted at 45.4 bu back then, yet the yield in the August report is predicted higher than last year, one has to wonder about the methodology of their survey."

Corn and soybean prices plunged on the news.

“What we’ve done is taken prices back down to the June lows or below that we had when we had the stocks report, where we were up 50 cents in beans and 30 cents in corn,” Gulke said. “Today we touched limit down in corn and limit down in beans.”

Listen to Jerry Gulke's special report for Farm Journal Radio:

What can farmers do? Sit tight.

“For the 40% of corn being grown in the United States that was in ‘poor’ to ‘very poor’ (condition according to this week’s Crop Progress report) and (if) that turns out to be where we’re at in the final analysis in October, there’s nothing much you can do here other than just wait it out and hope for a rally after harvest,” Gulke said.

The situation reminds the experienced market watcher of other notable years, such as 1993, when the Mississippi River overflowed its banks and flooded millions of acres.

“I liken this back to what happened in 1993 as well as 2010,” Gulke said. “We got totally hammered on one of those reports, and then the next report showed reduction in yields because as we harvested acres in September, October, November, December, and finally January, we found that yields weren’t quite as good. I have to be on the side of the camp now that says we’ve probably seen the highest production numbers.”

Back to news




Spell Check

Gary Charter
Ida, MI
8/12/2015 06:44 PM

  This is so far fetched it isn't funny. There are so many unplanted acres all over and the yield is up. In my 46 years as a farmer, I have never seen unplanted acres yield anything, but I must not know the new way of adding.

Timmonsville, SC
8/12/2015 07:25 PM

  USDA is trying to manipulate the market. They don't won't commodity prices to go up. Hurts the overall economy when commodities prices go up. They want the prices to stay as low as possible. Boost exports if prices are low and they are all about the numbers looking good.

Hillview, IL
8/13/2015 11:47 AM

  The USDA is just another corrupt government department! They are doing nothing but controlling the prices so the big wall street traders can make their millions! They don't care that the farmers can't pay bills with prices below production cost! There is no way that those yeilds estimates can come even close to thoses estimates! Every field has damage from way to much rain. You get back aways from the road and most feilds are filled with huge water holes, and stunted corn that will produce nothing! Thousands of acres didn't get planted or drowned out all together! The USDA has been bought off by our pc idiots in Washington to make them look good! They ought to be sued for revenue loss just like Syngenta! The USDA is as crooked as they come!


Corn College TV Education Series


Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!


Market Data provided by
Brought to you by Beyer