India Prepares to Exit China’s Grain Shadow

July 18, 2014 07:00 AM
India Prepares to Exit China’s Grain Shadow

Demand is always important. But for feed grains and biofuels, seldom has that mattered more than for the 2014/15 crop, with prospects of record yields, growing stocks and falling prices.

"How low can grain go? It boils down to exports," says Jean Philippe Gervais, chief agricultural economist for Farm Credit Canada.

In large part, that export outlook will be determined by China and a host of new demand players such as India. Internal factors such as income growth and demographic shifts must be heeded. That’s according to experts who gathered this week for the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City’s Ag Symposium.

Feed grain prices are more likely to model the low end of USDA’s forecast range, Gervais says. The agency has projected new-crop corn between $3.65 and $4.55. Prices likely will plateau over the next decade, though there is little risk that they will be below 1990 levels.

"There is a fairly wide consensus around global production increases for commodities, so pricing and income all hinges on demand," Gervais explains.

Cattle Prices Hit Corrective Phase

But even if food demand increases by 60% because of world population growth and changing diets—as projected by the Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO) of the United Nations—"world production would need to increase at levels much lower than in the past," he says. "This is really overlooked."

Although increases in gross domestic product (GDP) are often referenced as the key to future export growth, Gervais says another factor is more important. The global population also is rising, albeit at a declining rate.

"The biggest driver is incomes, not GDP," says Gervais. As incomes approach $20,000 in developing countries, the growth rate for food softens. Red meat consumption has upside in countries such as China, Russia and Brazil even though it is expected to stabilize in western countries.

Those factors mean the outlook for future grain demand is positive, even though prices will be lower in the next 10 years than in the preceding decade, Gervais says.

Policy also matters, Gervais says, as evidenced by the level of ag trade among the U.S., Canada and Mexico stimulated with the North American Free Trade Agreement. He foresees more bilateral trade agreements, but negotiating those deals isn’t always easy because countries have different values.

China Outlook Mixed, But India Rises

Although the global demand outlook is strong, projections for Chinese demand concern Gervais. USDA’s long-term projections assume linear growth of Chinese meat demand.

"But the linear trend will change," he cautions. At some point over the next five to 15 years, "demand growth will start to slow down."

Already, China’s economy is slowing down. But that might be good for North American grain exporters because it could give China the chance to adjust to a new economic reality. Growth in recent years, combined with a smaller workforce, could lead to higher wages that hurt Chinese competitiveness.


Want more? AgWeb readers are sharing fresh marketing insights every day. Click here to join the conversation, or to start your own.

As a result, "China has no choice but to increase productivity," Gervais says. "Its challenge is to rebalance its economy." Investment and consumption must be aligned more closely.

That’s especially true as China undergoes a major demographic shift, he says. Although the population of residents age 60 and older will grow rapidly through 2050, two groups will show significant declines—those ages 15 to 59, and newborns to age 14.

Focusing on China while ignoring other prospective customers is a mistake, agrees Chad Hart, ag economist at Iowa State University. He is optimistic about the long-term outlook of exports and biofuels, but he says China won’t remain the export growth story it is today.

Instead, India will surpass the country’s growth. Not only has the economy of India shown significant growth, but its population is forecast to grow from between 1.1 billion and 1.2 billion people to 1.8 billion by 2050. Meanwhile, the population of China, Japan and Russia will decline.

With that shift on the horizon, China may be viewed as a template for food demand in other countries over the next 35 to 40 years.

"Fifteen years from now, we will need to think elsewhere than China," Hart says. "Thirty years from now, that could be Africa." And China will remain an importer because it has just 5% of the world’s arable land—and 20% of its population.

Biofuels Present Global Opportunities

Farmers in the U.S. will not only see new avenues to export feed grains but also ethanol: China is expected to increase liquid fuel usage 222% from 2007 to 2035, followed by India (168%) and Africa (148%).

"Agriculture is an industry in transition, but we’re always adjusting to something," Hart notes. Biofuels will be part of the transition, though in some ways it’s a replay of a decades-old practice. In the early 1900s, for example, Iowa’s No. 2 crop—oats—fueled draft horses.

But biofuels demand largely depends on policies, "and there is a lot of uncertainty, not only in the U.S., but even in Brazil," Gervais says. Nonetheless, he foresees up to 60% growth in production over the next decade if ethanol is blended at 14%.

The one of just three regions that holds the key to future biofuel production, Hart says. That’s because of its soil types and growing conditions. The other regions are South America, specifically Brazil and Argentina, and the Black Sea region, particularly Ukraine. African production is possible in the long-term, but not on the same level.

Click here for more news and videos from Top Producer's Power Hour.

Back to news


Spell Check

No comments have been posted to this News Article

Corn College TV Education Series


Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!


Market Data provided by
Brought to you by Beyer