Phipps Book Review: How A Culture Of Safetyism Will Play Out

December 10, 2018 09:17 AM
 
While “The Coddling of the American Mind” by Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt is worth reading, the core argument strikes me as overdone. Read John Phipps's full review.

Lukianoff-Haidt-BookCover--PhippsReviewWhile “The Coddling of the American Mind” by Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt is worth reading, the core argument—that a culture of “safetyism” on college campuses is seriously damaging a generation of students—strikes me as overdone. The authors carefully outline how the turmoil on college campuses rests on untruths such as “what doesn’t kill me makes me weaker,” but their anecdotal approach needs more empirical data, not just well-reasoned argument. Their nuanced explanations are a powerful criticism of liberal thought as well as conservative dogma. However, many of us in college in the ’60s hold less concern that students and our culture can recover from such excesses as triggers and microaggressions. Been there, done that. To be blunt, the authors are academicians likely too close to the problem to fairly judge the ability of life after college to administer therapeutic value adjustment to young graduates. Indeed, while they discuss social media extensively, I find that phenomenon a more powerful culprit for social dysfunction, since it affects virtually all young people, not just college attendees.

Clearly, their belief overprotection (coddling) will have serious unfortunate impacts on members of iGen (born after 1995) is insightful. If they are closer to correct than I am, however, it means rural America will increasingly drift toward different cultural values than the vast majority of the U.S.

The book is thoughtful, polished and helpful for parents of pre-college children. My disagreements with their conclusions are of matter of degree, not fundamentals. —John Phipps

Back to news


Comments

 
Spell Check

Taylor
Beloit, WI
12/12/2018 05:24 AM
 

  John, Great review. Particularly good to see your clear identification of shortcomings of the material as well as your opposition to the author’s claim; but this especially you laid out the consequences and reasonable conclusions if you were wrong! Truly unique to see a writer deal with the other side of the argument in the public arena. It gives your position that much more credibility. Thanks

 
 

Corn College TV Education Series

2014_Team_Shot_with_Logo

Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!

Markets

Market Data provided by QTInfo.com
Brought to you by Beyer
Close