Shorting Chickens Becomes Hot Trade in Stock Market

05:08PM Nov 26, 2014
poultry chicken
( )

Short sellers have found a new asset to bet against: chickens.


With no futures market to speculate on chicken-price movements, they’re turning to the equity market, borrowing record amounts of shares of two U.S. poultry producers that they in turn sell in anticipation of declines. The percentage of outstanding shares of Pilgrim’s Pride Corp., the second-biggest U.S. chicken producer, that were sold short by investors has soared more than six-fold since Sept. 30, while the ratio for Sanderson Farms Inc. has almost doubled.

The success, or failure, of the trade comes down largely to whether the eight-month surge in chicken, which has fattened producers’ profit margins, is over or not. Prices for the whole bird have been soaring to a record, partly the result of rising beef costs that prompted consumers to turn to poultry as a cheaper protein substitute. Chicken output will expand to a record next year as lower grain prices help producers hold down costs, the U.S. Department of Agriculture estimates.

“The main issue for the lower prices is going to be because of the additional supply,” Altin Kalo, a livestock analyst with Steiner Consulting Group in Manchester, New Hampshire, said in a telephone interview Nov. 24. “It’s a little bit of a guess as to how big and how explosive the growth is going to be. It’s happened many times in the past where production starts to ramp up a lot faster than people expect.”


Sold Short

Almost 12 percent of outstanding stock in Pilgrim’s Pride was sold short on Nov. 24, up from less than 2 percent at the end of September. The company, a unit of JBS SA, is the biggest U.S. chicken producer after Tyson Foods Inc., which also sells pork and beef. Cameron Bruett, a spokesman for JBS USA, declined to comment.


Bearish bets against Sanderson Farms reached 36 percent this week, almost double what they were two months earlier.

While other agricultural products, including cattle, hogs, cotton and soybeans, trade on Chicago exchanges, chicken isn’t quoted on any U.S. bourse, making it hard to bet on the direction of prices.

Shares of Greeley, Colorado-based Pilgrim’s have surged 94 percent this year, partly the result of the jump in poultry prices. Laurel, Mississippi-based Sanderson, the fourth-biggest chicken producer, is up 20 percent. Sanderson Farms Chief Financial Officer Mike Cockrell declined to comment.


‘Peak’ Conditions

With higher chicken prices and lower feed costs, the industry has been “operating under the most advantageous conditions possible,” Francesco Pellegrino, a New York-based analyst for Sidoti & Co LLC, who recommends buying Sanderson Farms shares, said in a telephone interview yesterday. He doesn’t cover Pilgrim’s Pride. Short interest has risen because investors are questioning how much longer “peak” conditions can persist, he said.


Whole chickens sold by farmers in Georgia, the biggest producing state, rose 9.4 percent this year to an all-time high of $1.14 a pound, which has held through much of November. A retail gauge of composite wholesale-chicken prices has climbed 24 percent this year to average 90.404 cents a pound in October, USDA data show.

Chicken production will climb 3 percent next year to an all-time high of 39.206 billion pounds, the USDA forecasts. That’s at least 65 percent higher than estimated beef or pork output. A USDA index of chicken-feed costs was 24 percent lower in September than a year earlier as American farmers collect record corn and soybean crops.


Demand Outlook

Gains for demand will keep the “supply increases from crushing prices,” Heather Jones, a Richmond, Virginia-based analyst for BB&T Capital Markets, said in a telephone interview Nov. 24. Consumers “are going to see lower chicken prices, but nothing substantial,” she said.


Per-capita chicken consumption will rise to 85.3 pounds in 2015 from 83.4 pounds this year, the USDA estimates. The gain comes as the measure for beef is expected to decline 4.4 percent to 52.2 pounds. The smallest U.S. cattle herd since 1951 sent wholesale beef to a record in July, and the price is up 28 percent this year.

“In 2014, we have actually seen a demand shift from beef to chicken,” Donnie Smith, chief executive officer of Springdale, Arkansas-based Tyson, said during an investor presentation Nov. 19. The shift, combined with increased demand from younger consumers, gives “us a lot of confidence that we’re going to be chasing good demand particularly in chicken, and obviously pork as well, into the future,” he said.


Meat Inflation

While investors have benefited from anticipating profit- margin declines after peaks in past cycles, “these levels may be sustainable over the short-term,” Sidoti’s Pellegrino said. Demand for chicken will be helped by tight supplies of other meats for the next several years, he said.


U.S. meat prices will increase as much as 4.5 percent in 2015, the government estimates. The gains will be lead by beef, veal and pork, forecast to climb as much as 5.5 percent, the most of any food group. Poultry inflation is estimated between 2.5 percent and 3.5 percent.

The USDA expects wholesale-chicken prices could drop to as low as 99 cents a pound by the third quarter next year, from an average $1.052 in 2014.

Sanderson is the fourth-most shorted stock on the Nasdaq Composite Index, which has an average short interest of 2.8 percent, according to data compiled by Bloomberg and Markit, a London-based provider of financial information.

Producers have placed more chickens on feed than a year ago in every week since August, according to USDA data tracking the 19 largest-producing states. Prices for soybean meal, used in poultry feed, are down 10 percent this year. Futures in Chicago are heading for a second straight annual loss, the longest slide since 1998.

“In this business, we say cheap feed makes cheap meat,” Thomas Elam, the president of FarmEcon LLC in Carmel, Indiana, said in a telephone interview Nov. 21. “It’s just a matter of how long it’s going to take.”