Trade Deal Threatens Japan’s Food Security, Former Minister Says

May 15, 2015 10:21 AM
Trade Deal Threatens Japan’s Food Security, Former Minister Says

Japan’s food security and farm industry are threatened by a U.S.-led Pacific trade agreement supported by the government of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, according to a former Japanese agriculture minister.

The Trans-Pacific Partnership would deepen Japan’s dependence on agricultural imports, undermining its control over food safety and security, Masahiko Yamada, a lawyer and minister in 2010 in the then Democratic Party of Japan government, said in an interview Thursday in Tokyo.

The opposition may prove to be another barrier for efforts by Japan and the U.S., by far the biggest economies among TPP members, to expedite talks on the agreement. Japan, which imports about 60 percent of its food, cut its self-sufficiency target to 45 percent as the government expands trade deals.

Yamada, 73, said he plans to file a lawsuit against the government, claiming that the trade agreement violates the nation’s constitution. He will hold a press conference Friday to announce his plans.

“The TPP could violate the Japanese right to get stable food supply, or the right to live, guaranteed by Article 25 of the nation’s constitution,” said Yamada, who left the now- opposition party in 2012 as he was against then Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda’s push for Japan to join the TPP.

While Japan and the U.S. have yet to reach a bilateral accord to pave the way for the 12-nation agreement, U.S. Senate advanced a measure Thursday to allow President Barack Obama’s legislation to accelerate approval of trade pacts. Prospective members of the TPP have missed a series of deadlines since the U.S. announced its participation in 2009.

China Threat

A further delay to the deal raises the risk that China will set regional rules for commerce, after lining up 57 nations for the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, according to Tetsuhide Mikamo, director at Marubeni Research Institute in Tokyo.

The TPP could boost demand for Japan’s food exports among the 800 million people in the member nations, or 10 percent of global consumers, Agriculture Minister Yoshimasa Hayashi said in an interview last month. Abe has set a target of doubling the country’s shipments to 1 trillion yen ($8.4 billion) by 2020.

Japan may have to slash beef tariffs to 9 percent and pork tariffs to 50 yen a kilogram under the TPP, according to Yamada.

“That would be a fatal blow to Japanese livestock farmers,” he said. The country currently imposes 38.5 percent tariffs on beef and a maximum 482 yen/kg duty on pork.

‘100 Times’

Hiroshi Oe, Japan’s TPP ambassador, said rice is a politically sensitive product that must be protected, along with other grains, beef, pork, dairy and sugar crops. Economy Minister Akira Amari said last month that rice is “100 times” more important to Japan than it is to the U.S.

Yamada used to run cattle and hog farms in his hometown in the southern Japanese prefecture of Nagasaki before becoming a lower-house lawmaker in 1993. He said his dream of expanding his farms to become one of the country’s largest meat producers didn’t come true because a U.S. ban on soybean exports in 1973 sent livestock feed prices soaring, making his business unprofitable.

Back to news



Spell Check

d james
breman, IN
5/18/2015 04:07 PM

  To our friend in Japan, I remember 1973 soybean embargo. They screwed us both over. They are about to do it , again....Free Trade..???


Corn College TV Education Series


Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!


Market Data provided by
Brought to you by Beyer