U.S. Is Said to Make Dairy Proposal That Canada Flatly Rejects

October 16, 2017 05:17 PM
NAFTA flags

The Trump administration is proposing to dismantle a Canadian system of quotas and trade barriers for dairy and other foods that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government has regularly defended, setting up another flash-point in NAFTA negotiations.

The U.S. proposal, delivered Sunday during North American Free Trade Agreement talks, would fully eliminate tariffs over 10 years on so-called supply-managed products, according to two officials familiar with the measure, who spoke on the condition of anonymity as negotiations continue.

The U.S. is also seeking increased access to Canada’s milk and poultry markets, the officials said. In the case of milk, the U.S. is seeking roughly eight times the market share it agreed to in the Trans-Pacific Partnership, which U.S. President Donald Trump abandoned shortly after taking office, one of the officials said.

U.S. NAFTA negotiator John Melle confirmed the country is seeking to expand access for U.S. farmers to the Canadian market. “We made a request of Canada for improved access for dairy, poultry and eggs on Oct. 15,” Melle said in an emailed statement on Monday.

The Canadians have flatly rejected any mention of doing away with the supply-management system, which Canadian officials say prevents over-supply and guarantees stable pricing and production. Agriculture Minister Lawrence MacAulay reiterated Ottawa’s long-standing support for the system earlier on Monday.

“It’s a model for the world, and that’s in fact where we are. To deal with anything else is simply a non-starter,” he told reporters. “What’ll happen is difficult to know. We have very capable negotiators at the table, and it’s going to be done fair. We need a ‘right’ deal, and we’re not going to sign any deal.”

Canada’s supply-management system has long been controversial in trade talks, and was among the last issues resolved in TPP negotiations. The issue of dairy was left out of the original NAFTA accord.

Back to news




Spell Check

harmen waterlander
dublin, TX
10/17/2017 05:39 PM

  The Canadian milk-supply management system gives Canadians access to a local(very important as distances are huge and transportation costs accordingly) dairy product supply; may be not as cheap as in the U.S., but hauling product in from the U.S. would raise their store prices, too. Again, because of distance/transportation cost. For the U.S to push for eliminating the Canadian system is short sighted and greedy--leave them alone, and just may be look at their system and see what we can do with it....is it perfect? I think it may need some modifications. Is our system of milk pricing perfect? Just so you know, 26 years ago there were over 200,000 dairy farms in the U.S. now there are about 46.000 left....that's a sad story for a lot of farm families and a black eye for the industry leadership.


Corn College TV Education Series


Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!


Market Data provided by QTInfo.com
Brought to you by Beyer