What Research Revealed About Starter Fertilizer

March 23, 2016 10:10 AM
 
What Research Revealed About Starter Fertilizer

Does starter fertilizer pay? Several Extension agronomists aren’t completely convinced.

“Starter fertilizer will almost always give you bigger plants at V4 to V5 (corn) range, but yield response has always been erratic,” Joel DeJong, Iowa State Extension field agronomist recently told Farm Journal magazine. “It doesn’t always pay for itself – it just depends on the year.”

A series of 2015 trials from Purdue University revealed similar boost in early season plant height and accelerated plant development – but that didn’t always translate to better yields.

“Despite the consistent increases in plant growth and development and grain moisture at all locations resulting from starter fertilizer, increased yield only occurred at two of six locations,” write Jim Camberato, Cody Hornaday and Bob Nielsen.

The researchers admit there are likely other as-yet-unknown factors that influence corn’s response to starter fertilizer.

“[These] factors thought to influence corn response to starter fertilizer include soil temperature, the difference between air and soil temperature, soil nutrient level, soil strength, hybrid rooting pattern and vigor, seasonal rainfall, irrigation, and general yield level.”

The Purdue researchers say they will conduct additional studies over the next several years so they can better understand what effect more of these factors play in corn response to starter fertilizer. For a more complete recount of the 2015 trials, visit http://bit.ly/1PpIPxU.

Back to news


 

RELATED CONTENT

Comments

 
Spell Check

Woody
Wilcox, NE
7/9/2016 09:53 PM
 

  They say an increase in early growth was consistent in the tests which to me is a plus, get a jump on the weeds to shade the ground earlier. Also, if a guy has to put on phos anyway, why not put it in furrow where it belongs instead of on top of the ground.

 
 
Jeff
Dalton City, IL
3/23/2016 01:32 PM
 

  I find it interesting that you don't mention whether the tests were done on strip, no-till, or conventional. Strip and no-till will nearly always benefit from starter . Conventional tillage is more erratic. The fact that your research fails to mention any differences makes me question the entire resultof your "research".

 
 
Bryan
Lake Wilson, MN
6/21/2016 05:33 AM
 

  Jeff, I have tested it in strip till and did not see enough difference to get a return on it. Even on a cold wet spring when you would expect it the most did not see it. Its different for everyone but for me it did not help

 
 

Corn College TV Education Series

2014_Team_Shot_with_Logo

Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!

Markets

Market Data provided by QTInfo.com
Brought to you by Beyer
Close