Why Brazilian Farmers are Not Winning in US-China Spat

July 19, 2018 03:45 PM
These should be jubilant times across the sprawling soybean fields of Brazil with the China-U.S. trade war pushing buyers to search the globe for alternatives to American soy, But that may not be the case.

(Bloomberg) --

These should be jubilant times across the sprawling savanna of southeastern Brazil. Soybean is king here. And with the China-U.S. trade war pushing Chinese buyers to frantically search the globe for alternatives to American soy, Brazil is the most logical first stop.

But not only are farmers not boosting sales to take advantage of this sudden jump in demand -- and prices -- they’re actually halting them.

In an untimely twist that seems to epitomize everything that’s gone wrong with Brazil’s economy in recent years, the government imposed a rule change in late May that pushed up freight costs as much as 150 percent, squeezing farmers’ profit margins so much that many are just letting the remaining soy from the last harvest pile up in silos along with corn that’s currently being reaped.

In other words, even when the country is handed an absolute gift -- a surefire victory produced by a geopolitical squabble far away -- it squanders the moment. Sure, the transport increase could be rolled back in time for farmers to start tapping into the higher prices. But what if the U.S.-China spat fades quickly?

‘Blowing’ an Opportunity

“We may be blowing a great opportunity,” says Bartolomeu Braz Pereira, head of Aprosoja, the soybean association that is Brazil’s biggest farm group.

Take the example of Ricardo Arioli, a farmer in Mato Grosso state, the heart of soybean country. He froze advanced sales on his 2018-2019 harvest weeks ago and at this point has only sold 8 percent of that crop. At this time last year, he had already sold 40 percent of the upcoming harvest.

"Nobody wants to buy or sell soybeans,” Arioli, 58, said. “Farmers are the most hurt by this situation.”

The minimum freight cost rule was rolled out in May in a bid to appease truckers who had launched a nationwide strike to protest surging fuel costs. The strike lasted 10 days, long enough to cause the biggest one-month drop in Brazil’s economic activity gauge since at least 2003. Ironically, farmers were originally supporting the strike because they thought it would lead to lower fuel prices. None of them were expecting the government’s solution would be a mandatory increase in freight charges.

‘Stuck With the Bill’

Farmers are bearing the brunt of the added expenses because the traders who buy from producers and export the crop usually discount freight costs from prices paid to growers.

The freeze on farmer sales isn’t having much impact on traders so far, since they’re exporting from stockpiled supplies. That means the middleman is reaping the lion’s share of the wealth as domestic soybean premiums surge on robust Chinese demand. The price has more than doubled since June 1 to $2.30 a bushel.

“Farmers will get stuck with the bill,” Arioli said. “I’m sure about that.”

Adding to the confusion: several industrial and agriculture groups have challenged the new freight laws in court. Grain selling has almost completely dried up thanks to the murky outlook.

"Premiums and exchange rates are in our favor,” said Pereira of Aprosoja. “We should be making big sales, but this is not happening because of the freight uncertainty.”

The freight obstacles may also hurt production for the next crop, according to Pereira, who is also a farmer in Goias state. Higher transport costs mean fertilizer prices have jumped about 20 percent from a year ago, according to Mato Grosso’s rural economy institute Imea. Deliveries have also been halted. Producers may be forced to delay seeding or they could decide to reduce fertilizer use, which may hurt yield potential, Pereira said.

"Internal problems have stopped us from taking advantage of the battle between China and the U.S.,” he said.


Copyright 2018, Bloomberg

Back to news


Spell Check

Vico Peißker
Moscow, WY
8/29/2018 07:08 AM

  We are please to inform your esteem buying company the petroleum products you are looking for is available in our storage tanks, We have an official FOB and CIF offer (Fob Rotterdam). We guarantee truth and professionalism, We will be ready to cooperate with you in various products. to ship to our customers. and reservoir for immediate delivery Such as: Jp54 Gross price $46/ Net $44. Minimum Order is 2,000,000 barrels / month JA1 Gross price $46/ Net $44. Minimum Order is 2,000,000 barrels / month D2 indent $ 380 / $ 370. Minimum Order 100,000mt / month D6 Gross $0.80 cent USD per Gallon Net $ 0.70cent USD Provide your official email or contact us via email to enable us issue our official soft corporate offer (SCO).Thanks. BELOW IS OUR CONTACT INFORMATION, E-mail: neftegazoiltrading@yandex.ru E: neftegazoiltrading_sale@mail.ru E: neftegazoiltrading_sale@yahoo.com Skype: neftegazoiltrading Best Regards (Mr.) Vico Peißker. Skype: neftegazoiltrading Thank You

Jamestown, SC
10/30/2018 09:51 AM

  Do You Seek Funds To Pay Off Credits and Debts? { FIFOCapitals@gmail.com } Is Here To Put A Stop To Your Financial Problems. We Offer All Kinds Of Loan (Personal Loan, Commercial Loan, etc.) We Give Out Loan With An Interest Rate Of 1.00%. Interested Applicants Should Contact Us Via Email: FIFOCapitals@gmail.com Please Fill the Application Form Below: - Complete Name: - Loan Amount Needed: - Loan Duration: - Purpose Of Loan: - City / Country: - Telephone: - How Did You Hear About Us: If You Are Interested To Get A Loan Then Kindly Write Us With The Loan Requirement. Please, Contact Us via email: FIFOCapitals@gmail.com,,,

Kuznetsov GAVRIIL Mikhailovich
Moscow, CA
9/27/2018 03:10 AM

  Our company PETROLEUM CORP is the most viable and efficient connection between real buyers and sellers for all principal energy commodities. We trade in several commodities not limited to AVIATION KEROSENE’S, namely, JET FUEL (JP54), VIRGIN DIESEL FUEL OIL (D6), DIESEL GASOIL (D2), MAZUT etc. and also in BONNY LIGHT, OTHER CRUDES AND COALS. We currently serve any world port. If you are a buyer or direct mandate to a performing buyer please feel free to contact us. Please contact us via our official email address. kuznetsovgavriil.mikhailovich@mail.ru Thanks. Kuznetsov GAVRIIL Mikhailovich


Corn College TV Education Series


Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!


Market Data provided by QTInfo.com
Brought to you by Beyer