Will New Dicamba Soybeans Deliver Higher Yields?

November 25, 2016 09:10 AM
Will New Dicamba Soybeans Deliver Higher Yields?

Earlier in November, the Environmental Protection Agency placed its seal of approval for over-the-top use of dicamba herbicide in soybeans. That’s good news for soybean growers wanting more weed-control options. But will new dicamba-resistant varieties also be able to boost yields?

“New doesn’t always mean it is automatically better,” cautions Shawn Conley, soybean and wheat Extension specialist with the University of Wisconsin.

According to Conley, the Wisconsin Soybean Program evaluated 200 Roundup Ready 2 Yield and 47 Roundup Ready 2 Xtend soybean varieties. On average, across all varieties and regions, the RR2Y varieties out-yielded RR2X by 1.8 bu. per acre. That’s significant, he says.

“RR2X soybeans are a stack of herbicide traits and not yield traits,” he says. “These traits protect yield, not enhance yield. Remember this point with all pest-management traits.”

Conley recommends using independent trial data and selecting varieties that not only perform well, but also contain the desired traits. That doesn’t mean discounting the threat of resistant weeds, either. Much more than 1.8 bu. per acre could be at stake in vulnerable areas.

“I just want to reiterate that every variety must stand on its own as well as remind growers to use multiple modes of action and consider incorporating other traits such as LibertyLink soybeans into your soybean weed management plans,” he says. “All of the data and models I have seen suggest that the dicamba-tolerant crops’ shelf life will be much shorter than the original Roundup if we don’t’ manage this technology correctly.”

For more integrated pest and crop management from UW, visit http://ipcm.wisc.edu/

Back to news



Spell Check

TJ Wilson
Kiron, IA
11/25/2016 10:49 AM

  I have grown RR2X seed beans 2 years in a row. They yielded 57 the 1st year, and 54 this year. I grew Liberty seed beans 1/4 mile away both years too. 2 years ago the Liberty beans out yielded the RR2X by 1.5 bushels. This year the Liberty beans out yielded the RR2X by 6 bushels. I'm confident the RR2X beans do not perform as well yet. I have 2 years of hard data to prove it.

Central Illinois farmer
Clinton, IL
11/28/2016 07:35 AM

  With dicamba having such a short residual life, I really see this as a rescue herbicide only. You had better be putting down products with much longer residual lifespan to stop problem weeds before they sprout. People I talk with think this is the golden bullet for weed control, I do not know if salesmen are pumping them full of "sunshine" or they have not sat down with a reputable agronomist who understands products.

Essex, MO
11/27/2016 04:11 PM

  Ten bushel less than conventional beans in Southeast Mo.


Corn College TV Education Series


Get nearly 8 hours of educational video with Farm Journal's top agronomists. Produced in the field and neatly organized by topic, from spring prep to post-harvest. Order now!


Market Data provided by QTInfo.com
Brought to you by Beyer