Scheve: Questions To Ask Anyone About Their Market Opinions
May 21, 2018
Market Commentary for 5/18/18
July corn has been range bound the last month. Following are the Friday afternoon closing prices over the last four weeks:
- 5/18 - $4.02
- 5/11 - $3.96
- 5/2 - $4.06
- 4/27 - $3.98
The market is waiting for June weather to determine direction. Also, trade issues are still a wildcard that won't likely be resolved soon.
Thoughts about Market Analyses
Generally I think grain marketing information directed to farmers is often too broad and general to be helpful. I suspect that's because those discussing the markets don't want to commit too far in one direction for fear of being wrong. That is understandable and reasonable to a point, but being too general isn't very helpful either. To minimize general statements or broad ranges there are a few easy questions one can ask that I think provides more focused and helpful information.
Be More Specific When Using The Terms "Bullish" And "Bearish"
When I hear "I’m bullish today" or " I’m bearish right now" I don't know what they mean because the terms are too subjective. One bullish person may think corn will rally 25 cents, while another thinks $1. Both of these thoughts are technically bullish, but they are very different estimates. Instead, a better question would be, "How bullish or bearish are you?" By being more specific, farmers can have a better perspective of potential.
What Are The Chances The Market Will Move To A Certain Level
Recently an analyst said they thought corn could rally from $4 to $4.50 on the July futures. That would be music to farmer ears; however, given what we know today it might be a long shot. I wish there had been a follow up question, "what are the odds that will happen?" Sure corn could go up to $4.50 by July, or $5 by Christmas, and even $8 by next July, but there are a lot of market variables involved for $5 to happen and even more for $8. The higher the rally, the harder and less likely it becomes.
If someone told me there is a 10% chance of $4.50 corn versus a 50% chance, that’s a big difference. I find that unless someone can provide the odds and the reasons of a price point happening, their statement is of little use to me when I’m making marketing decisions.
Provide More Defined Timeframes
I also find little value when someone tells me they think corn could trade between $4.20 and $4.50 without providing a timeframe. Will corn be between $4.20 and $4.50 by July 4th, Labor Day or Thanksgiving? Providing price estimates without time frame doesn't help me much in planning decisions.
Provide Narrower Price Ranges
Farmers' profits can range significantly when the market moves from $4.20 to $4.50, so estimating this broad of a range doesn't help me much. Instead, a tighter range of about 10 cents provides me with more clarity.
On the surface some may think this isn't that big of a deal. But, it's important when considering what the average farmer is hearing when these ranges are said. Farmers tend to hear the upside of wide ranges instead of the low side. In this example, I hear there is a chance for $4.50, so I'm more likely to disregard the $4.20 level. This may mean I'll wait longer than I should to start selling some grain.
Know That Nobody Knows
Despite the confidence of anyone with a market opinion, no one knows where prices are going. It's easy to assume that maybe analysts who study the markets every day have some kind of insider secrets no one else knows, but they don't because nobody can predict weather, the biggest driver of prices long term. The only information market analysts might have a better handle on, than the average farmer, is knowing how the market variables could affect supply and demand, and therefore price potential. However, they still don't know how much these variables will affect prices.
Because no one knows where prices will go, many prefer to provide grain market information that is as general as possible. I understand and can appreciate that, but maybe using the above questions as a guideline could help farmers be more realistic with their chances for the market. This could potentially lead them to developing a better foundation for their grain marketing plans. I always try to be critical of grain marketing information from any source, whether it’s a farmer, broker, elevator manager or any analysts. In doing so, my grain marketing is based upon more realistic expectations.
Superior Feed Ingredients, LLC
9358 Oak Ave
Waconia, MN 55387
This email material is for the sole use of the intended recipient, and cannot be reproduced, disseminated, distributed or electronically transmitted, including any attachments, without the prior written permission of Superior Feed Ingredients, LLC.. Even though the information contained herein is believed to be reliable, we cannot guarantee its accuracy or completeness, and the views and opinions expressed are subject to change without notice. Trading commodities involves risk and one should fully understand those risks before buying or selling futures or options. This data is provided for information purposes only and is not intended to be used for specific trading strategies.