Caught in the Crossfire: How White House Policies Are Rattling Cattle Country

From immigration enforcement disruptions in Kansas to the White House’s decision to increase beef imports, cattle producers feel the impact of Washington’s policies, and midterm results may signal growing frustration.

The beef industry is caught in the middle of some major policy decisions coming out of Washington. From immigration enforcement and workforce challenges to beef imports and domestic processing investments, the Trump administration’s policies are creating both opportunities and uncertainty for cattle producers.

And the political implications are becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.

The November midterm elections delivered a blue wave across much of the country, including several key races in cattle-producing states. In southwest Kansas, three counties in the heart of the state’s meatpacking Golden Triangle shifted blue in the Senate race. The results came just weeks after a large-scale immigration enforcement operation disrupted beef processing in the region.

At the same time, the administration’s decision to temporarily allow 300,000 metric tons of additional ground beef imports into the U.S. tariff-free for 90 days has created another point of contention between the White House and cattle producers.

For an industry already navigating tight cattle supplies, elevated prices and a complicated processing landscape, those policy decisions are having real-world consequences.

President Trump on Immigration

Just days after the midterm elections, President Donald Trump sat down for his first one-on-one interview following the results, acknowledging that his administration’s immigration crackdown had both helped and hurt politically.

In an interview with 60 Minutes just days after the midterms, Trump defended his administration’s border policies, saying he believes he deserves high marks for securing the border and removing criminals. However, he also acknowledged the divide over what should happen to people who entered the country illegally but have since established jobs and lives in the U.S.

That tension is particularly evident in southwest Kansas, where the beef industry depends heavily on immigrant labor.

September ICE Raids Impact on Southwest Kansas

Matt Teagarden, CEO of the Kansas Livestock Association (KLA), says immigration enforcement activity had been ongoing in the region for months. However, a large-scale operation in September brought a much more visible federal presence, including checkpoints and increased enforcement activity.

“There’s been ICE agents in southwest Kansas for months doing investigative work, finding and apprehending criminals and doing that work. So it’s really been ongoing,” Teagarden says. “What happened in September was one of those very visible, widespread, broad-scale enforcement actions.”

Teagarden says the operation involved more than simply targeting specific individuals. The tactics used, including road checkpoints and a highly visible law enforcement presence, created additional disruptions throughout the region.

“I think they had a list of individuals that they were targeting, but the tactics in which they were pursuing those individuals were more the checkpoints on the roads and a big visible presence,” he says.

The operation disrupted beef processing in three major Kansas communities: Dodge City, Garden City and Holcomb. Together, those communities account for approximately 20% to 25% of the nation’s fed cattle processing capacity, Teagarden says. The impact was immediate.

“The first word we got was from members who were reporting to us that cattle had been canceled,” Teagarden says. “Cattle scheduled for harvest that week were canceled because of the disruptions at the plants, and even a handful of folks that had delivered cattle were called to pick them back up and return them to the feedyard.”

The region also experienced a nearly 10% decline in cattle slaughter in a single day.

Fear That Impacted Livestock Farms

But the disruption extended beyond the processing facilities. Teagarden says feedyards and dairies also began reporting employee attendance issues as the increased immigration enforcement presence created uncertainty throughout the community.

He says the difference between targeted enforcement and large-scale operations is significant, particularly in communities where immigrant families have lived and worked for generations.

“It’s this kind of big, flashy, big presence, and we’ve seen it across the country, and it just creates an environment of fear for everybody in the community and particularly those that are some version of an immigrant,” Teagarden says. “Even those that have been in the U.S. for years, multiple generations in the U.S., they’re fearful of leaving home because they don’t want to deal with that. They don’t want to have a situation go bad and end up locked up or something go wrong and end in a bad result.”

KLA, along with neighboring livestock organizations in Oklahoma and Texas, brought the concerns to Washington, emphasizing the impact the operation was having on the region’s livestock industry. Ultimately, Department of Homeland Security officials acknowledged the situation had gone too far, and additional agents left the area.

Teagarden emphasizes the livestock industry is not opposed to border security or efforts to apprehend criminals.

“Absolutely,” Teagarden says when asked whether KLA supports the president’s efforts to secure the border and target criminals. “We’ve said for years, we’ve worked immigration workforce issues for years, that step one is securing the border. And the president’s done that. That’s done, job done, which I think puts us in a really good position to talk about this issue and really look at solutions.”

Stephen Miller’s Promotion Raises Questions About Immigration Reform

The immigration debate took another turn following the midterms when Trump promoted Stephen Miller, a key architect of the administration’s hardline immigration policies, to chief of staff.

For Teagarden, the appointment was difficult to reconcile with the election results.

“My first reaction was that appointment doesn’t track with the results last Tuesday,” Teagarden says. “I think if you look at some key races in Kansas and Texas, there was pushback on that kind of widespread deport-everybody kind of approach. I think there’s a clear connection.”

He says the appointment raises questions about whether the administration is recognizing the message voters sent in communities where agriculture and food production depend on immigrant labor.

“Maybe that means he’s going to focus on more things than just maybe largely or maybe solely focused on immigration and mass deportations,” Teagarden says. “So maybe that’s the silver lining here.”

On the day of Miller’s promotion, he praised the president for securing the border but did not detail any new immigration policy shifts.

Hope for Immigration Reform

Trump, however, indicated in his 60 Minutes interview that he believes there may be an opportunity to work with Democrats on immigration legislation, saying people had already contacted him about a potential deal.

That possibility gives Teagarden some optimism.

He points to the Securing Agriculture’s Workforce Act, legislation introduced by House Agriculture Committee Chairman Glenn “GT” Thompson, as an example of a potential path forward. The proposal addresses many of the workforce challenges agriculture faces.

“The president multiple times has acknowledged the need to address this,” Teagarden says. “We’ve spent a lot of time talking about Chairman Thompson’s bill, the Securing Agriculture’s Workforce Act. It addresses many, nearly all, from an ag perspective, the issues that we see.”

“I guess I remain optimistic that there is support for reform, common-sense reform,” he adds.

His message to the administration is straightforward: Recognize the progress made on border security, then turn attention toward a workable agricultural labor solution.

“The other thing that I would share is the importance of immigrants, and again, it’s first-generation, second-generation, third-generation immigrants, to our food production system,” Teagarden says. “And if we’re going to produce food in the U.S., we have to have these workers.”

He believes the choice facing the country is relatively simple.

“We can either import our workers or import our food,” Teagarden says. “And I think it comes down to that as simple as that.”

White House Beef Import Decision Sparks Backlash, Controversy

While immigration policy has created workforce challenges for beef processors, another White House decision has generated frustration among cattle producers and possibly swayed votes: the administration’s move to increase ground beef imports.

The administration’s plan to bring in an additional 300,000 metric tons of ground beef tariff-free for 90 days was intended to help address high beef prices for consumers. But the market reaction has been complicated.

A recent Farm Action analysis of the administration’s beef import plan also points to a significant impact on cattle producers.

According to the organization, ranchers have received nearly 20% less for cows used in ground beef production since the import plan began, representing approximately $319 per animal. The analysis says packers are paying less, while consumers are seeing only modest savings.

For producers already facing a tight cattle supply and a volatile market, the import announcement has become another source of frustration with Washington.

A Balancing Act for the Future of the Beef Industry

The competing policy decisions coming out of Washington highlight the challenges facing the beef industry.

On one hand, cattle producers and processors are looking for solutions to workforce shortages and greater certainty surrounding immigration policy. On the other, producers want policies that strengthen domestic cattle markets rather than introduce additional volatility through increased imports.

Meanwhile, the administration is promoting investments in regional processing capacity as a way to create more competition and expand opportunities for independent operators.

For Teagarden, the importance of immigrant labor to the nation’s food production system cannot be overlooked. As Washington considers its next steps on immigration, trade and domestic food production, the stakes extend well beyond the political arena. The decisions will help shape the future of America’s beef supply chain, from the feedyard and packing plant to the grocery store.

AgWeb-Logo crop
Related Stories
Sixth-generation farmer Sam Graves is preparing to leave Congress after 26 years, but says agriculture still faces a growing challenge in Washington: helping lawmakers understand what it takes to produce America’s food supply.
A Navy SEAL with Ag Committee seniority faces a dairy farmer who lived the economics that forced her family to sell after 150 years. Both want your vote.
Facing a delayed Farm Bill and cost pressures, rural Kansans decide between a senior Ag Committee Republican and a pastor pledging bipartisan independence.
Read Next
The southern rust outbreak everyone prepared for never arrived, but late-season rots and unexpected tar spot pressure kept growers on their toes. Two Extension pathologists share why this season’s biggest lesson is learning to adapt, not react.
Get News Daily
Get Market Alerts
Get News & Markets App