John Phipps’ Book Review: You Look Like a Thing and I Love You

In “You Look Like a Thing and I Love You,” Janell Shane briskly dismantles this pretension with anecdote, humor, and just enough hard science to educate.

Books
Books
(AgWeb)

Nothing signals technological hipness more than sprinkling conversations with references to artificial intelligence (AI). In “You Look Like a Thing and I Love You,” Janell Shane briskly dismantles this pretension with anecdote, humor, and just enough hard science to educate.

The title is the result of a typical experiment – a pickup line generated by an AI (although I think I might have used it back in the day). Using the term AI really signals you’re probably talking about science fiction – Data or C3PO. The more accurate nomenclature is machine learning, with the emphasis on learning.

Shane throws ponds of cold water on our AI fantasies, then triggers trepidations about real possibilities, and repetitively provides examples of how hard the most basic human tasks are for even sophisticated machines. Narrow challenges (chess) are trivial compared to dealing with messy, irrational reality, not to mention humans.

For farmers, her explanation of why our data is coveted by industry will surprise, and certainly prompt more uneasiness.

Those of us hoping for widespread labor-eliminating robotics get a sobering but realistic update. While the book is short, it could have used a better editor, and illustrations of nonsense from AI training efforts run on too long.

Still, readers walk away with a usable grasp of this technology now (powerful but limited) and where it may be going near-term (significant knowledge-worker replacement). Sample her work at aiweirdness.com. Kindle version is fine, but some illustrations are far better on tablet.

AgWeb-Logo crop
Related Stories
Iowa State research reveals PI 88788 resistance is losing effectiveness at 2% per year, with yield losses potentially reaching 9 bushels per acre by decade’s end if management practices are unchanged.
NASDA and the National Agricultural Law Center say a new project tracking both Chapter 11 and Chapter 12 filings offers a more complete view of agricultural bankruptcies — with California, Arkansas, Georgia and Iowa leading the initial dataset.
New research builds on growing state and federal scrutiny by asking what these laws could mean for land prices and productivity.
Get News Daily
Get Market Alerts
Get News & Markets App