Organic Versus Conventional--Can’t Everyone Just Get Along?

When you hear the term ‘organic’ it likely evokes some kind of strong emotion. For consumers, it’s a positive reaction, but for many conventional farmers it provokes animosity.

Joel Layman is 100% organic but used to farm all conventional. While there are differences in production, he says everyone is needed to produce food and fiber for the world.
Joel Layman is 100% organic but used to farm all conventional. While there are differences in production, he says everyone is needed to produce food and fiber for the world.
(Joel Layman)

When you hear the term ‘organic’ it likely evokes some kind of strong emotion. For consumers, it’s a positive reaction, but for many conventional farmers it provokes animosity. For Michigan farmer Joel Layman, it was a tough row to hoe when switching his farm, employees and family to organic from conventional production.

“I remember driving home and thinking ‘How am I going to break the news to my full-time guys?’” he says. “I thought they were going to throw me out of the shop. I’d won the battle in my own mind, but now I had to win over my local support system.”

That system includes employees, family, bankers, input suppliers, crop insurance agents and neighbors. In addition, he’s battling the ever-criticizing public eye.

“Conventional ag feels targeted by organic and feels like everyone is saying they’re doing a bad job—they’re getting defensive,” Layman says. “They put their heart and soul into their crop and think people are passing judgement, it’s natural to get defensive. But, on the other side, as an organic farmer the first thing conventional farmers do when they talk to me is tear down what I do.”

He’s convinced his employees, family, bankers and suppliers. But for neighbors and fellow farmers? It’s still an uphill battle, and he hopes one day everyone will be more accepting of all farming methods.

“I hate chickens, but I thank God there are people who want to raise them,” Layman says. “It takes us all—organic, conventional and everything in between.”

AgWeb-Logo crop
Related Stories
Joe Kooima of Kooima Kooima Varilek says the cattle futures have run into chart resistance after a big week last week and are correcting with disappointing cash.
Jim McCormick of AgMarket says beyond the tailwind of a friendly WASDE Report there were several factors that drove the rally in the grain market this week and may have confirmed the lows.
The southern rust outbreak everyone prepared for never arrived, but late-season rots and unexpected tar spot pressure kept growers on their toes. Two Extension pathologists share why this season’s biggest lesson is learning to adapt, not react.
Read Next
First-time detections in Iowa and Alabama highlight the importance of accurate identification and proactive seed treatment strategies.

Get News Daily
Get Market Alerts
Get News & Markets App