Weather Extremes Are Eating Your Thanksgiving Pie

From historic wheat lows to frost-damaged apples and scorched pumpkin fields, climate whiplash is driving up ingredient costs and forcing bakers to get creative — with heat-tolerant sweetpotatoes emerging as a rare bright spot.

pumpkin pie on wood background
Extreme heat, droughts and heavy rains have pushed pumpkin prices up to an average of $6.20 this year — taking a literal bite out of our favorite holiday desserts.
(Photo: M.studio, Adobe Stock)

In the weeks leading up to Thanksgiving, Los Angeles baker Rose Wilde heard something from local growers that she says made her and her fellow chefs audibly gasp: Farmers weren’t sure they would have enough apples to make it to the holiday.

For Wilde, owner of Red Bread Bakery, the Thanksgiving rush is the financial lifeline that pays the rent for the next two months and carries her business through a slow January. Refusing to take apples off the menu, she bought up fruit early, cooked the fillings ahead of time and froze them — abandoning her usual fresh-baked workflow just to hedge against erratic supply. She even filmed a video reviving a Great Depression-era “mock apple pie” recipe that swaps out scarce apples for crackers.

“That creativity is wonderful when it’s our choice and something we pursue,” Wilde says. “But when we don’t have any choice, and we are just adapting as fast as we can, it becomes very problematic to stay in business and feed people.”

Wilde’s kitchen scramble was one of the stark realities shared during a Nov. 17 virtual briefing hosted by the Climate Action Campaign (CAC). Timed to highlight a new CAC report examining how extreme weather is reshaping the holiday dessert table, the webinar brought together scientists, economists and culinary leaders to explain why classic Thanksgiving staples are becoming harder to source — and why the prices shoppers and diners pay rarely come back down.

Climate Whiplash Hits the Harvest

Agriculture relies on predictable weather, yet farmers are increasingly facing violent swings between historic heat, floods, droughts and unseasonable frosts, says Omanjana Goswami, a scientist with the food and environment program at the Union of Concerned Scientists.

Drawing from both the webinar and the CAC report, that volatility has taken a direct toll on nearly every ingredient in a traditional Thanksgiving pie:

  • Wheat — The foundation of the pie crust suffered one of its worst years in four decades. Hit by extreme drought and late-season freezes, particularly in major growing states like Kansas, the 2026 U.S. wheat harvest plunged by roughly 25%, marking its lowest level since 1972.
  • Apples — Shorter winters and sudden spring cold snaps prematurely awakened fruit trees before devastating orchards from New York to Wisconsin. Some Mid-Atlantic orchards canceled their fall picking seasons entirely; New York growers face more than $30 million in losses, and the overall U.S. apple crop is projected to be 7% smaller this year. Meanwhile, extreme summer heat and warm nights in top-producing counties such as Washington’s Yakima County are causing apple “sunburn” and dulling fruit color.
  • Pumpkins — Following the country’s hottest summer on record, extreme heat nearly wiped out some Texas pumpkin farms, while drought and wildfire smoke in Utah kept pollinators away, resulting in the worst harvest in decades for some growers. Heavy June rains in top-producing Illinois and in Connecticut also dampened yields and kept farm visitors at home. Together, these shocks pushed the average retail price of a pumpkin to $6.20 this year, up from $5.50 in 2023 and roughly $4 in 2020.
  • Pecans — Extreme heat spikes pecans’ water demands, while heavy rainfall and humidity fuel fungal scourges like pecan scab, which plagued south Georgia growers this year. That follows Hurricane Helene in 2024, which cut pecan production by 75% in Georgia, the nation’s top producer, while severe drought and heat threaten top-producing New Mexico and Arizona and Super El Niño flooding inundates pecan groves in the Southwest.
  • Chocolate — Back-to-back droughts in West Africa, which produces 70% of the world’s cocoa, and torrential rains and fungal pod rot in Latin America have triggered historic price shocks. Cacao prices hit a record high of over $12,000 per ton in 2024, up from a historic average of $2,000 to $3,000. Retail chocolate prices are up 9.4% over last year, and manufacturers are increasingly cutting cocoa content with fillers like palm and shea oils.
  • Cranberries — Because cranberries require a specific number of winter chill hours between 32°F and 45°F to flourish, rapidly warming winters in top-producing Wisconsin are putting future harvests at risk and forcing growers to invest in new bog-sanding techniques and smart irrigation systems.
Screenshot (693).png
(Image captured from CAC webinar)

Why Grocery Bills and Menu Prices Stay High

While headlines frequently note that overall food inflation has cooled from its pandemic-era peaks, shoppers aren’t feeling relief at the checkout counter. According to David Ortega, a professor of food economics and policy at Michigan State University, that is because a slower rate of inflation doesn’t mean prices are falling; the overall price level simply keeps climbing.

Unlike temporary shocks such as geopolitical conflicts or supply chain bottlenecks, climate change acts as a slow, permanent ratchet on food costs. While roughly 9 cents of every retail food dollar goes back to the farm, extreme weather inflates costs all along the supply chain. Drought-lowered water levels in the Mississippi River and the Panama Canal have forced shipping barges to detour, while prolonged heat waves drive up energy bills for refrigeration and air conditioning.

At the retail level, grocery stores can largely pass those higher input costs onto consumers, hitting hardest low-income households that spend a much larger share of their disposable income on food.

Independent restaurants and bakeries, however, don’t have that luxury. Operating on thin profit margins of just 3% to 5%, chefs risk driving away customers if they raise menu prices too high, forcing them to absorb the losses themselves.

“When, as a consumer, you’re seeing the price at the grocery store of certain ingredients going up, know that at the chef’s equivalent of a grocery store, it’s the same thing,” says Anne McBride, vice president of impact for the James Beard Foundation.

She says when local crops fail, like Pennsylvania apples, chefs have to source fruit from out of state or overseas, eroding both their margins and their commitment to local farms.

A Resilient Bright Spot on the Dessert Table

Despite the grim outlook for crusts, apples and pumpkins, both the CAC report and the panelists point to one classic holiday ingredient thriving amid the chaos: the sweetpotato.

Naturally heat-tolerant and adapted to warm temperatures, sweetpotatoes have proven remarkably resilient to extreme weather compared to other struggling crops. For McBride, that resilience emphasizes a promising path forward. Across the country, chefs are partnering more closely with local farmers to share the risk of planting climate-hardy crops, guaranteeing growers a market while educating diners on new, adaptable menus.

As Goswami says, fixing the food system doesn’t require inventing new science from scratch; the solutions already exist. Paired with transitioning toward clean, reliable energy to curb the root cause of extreme weather, experts say directing funding and support into the hands of farmers and local food businesses can keep the holiday table intact.

AgWeb-Logo crop
Related Stories
DuWayne Bosse of Bolt Marketing says the grain market is seeing pressure from the higher dollar, December option expiration and nervousness about the meeting between President Trump and Xi.
Mike Zuzolo of Global Commodity Analytics says wheat added risk premium, while corn and soybeans saw nervousness ahead of the Trump, Xi meeting.
Vince Boddicker of Farmer’s Trading Company sees the grain rally Tuesday as fund buying as the market continues to try to bottom.
Read Next
“As bad as it is right now,” says producer Tim Gomes, “this whole theft situation in agriculture is about to get crazier and crazier.”
Get News Daily
Get Market Alerts
Get News & Markets App