The Strategy That Makes Every Input Earn Its Place

Through on-farm research, Sam Bennett and Jon Bakehouse have learned to identify which practices deliver value and which ones don’t. Here’s how they do it.

inputs
Farmers are asking more questions about which inputs provide ROI and are determining the answers in their own fields.
(Lindsey Pound)

When Sam Bennett’s dad looked out at a field of soybeans growing through knee-high cereal rye, he probably thought his son had lost his mind. But Bennett wasn’t gambling — he was conducting research.

“That was a scary thing to tell my dad and brother: ‘I’m just not going to spray some of the beans with a pre-emerge,’” Bennett says during a webinar hosted by GROW and Practical Farmers of Iowa (PFI).

The only herbicide used in the trial was to terminate the cover crop. The surprising result? Equal yields between the treated and untreated soybeans with significantly reduced herbicide costs in the untreated trial.

“I’ve done it enough now that I know where I can skip or reduce herbicide or change up the application timing and make that cover crop work harder,” says Bennett who farms in west-central Iowa, near Galva. There, his family raises corn, soybeans, small grains and hay across about 2,000 acres in conventional and organic production.

The Power of the Paired Strip Trial

Stefan Gailans, who leads PFI’s cooperator program, explained that the organization’s 10,000-plus members use a deceptively simple tool: the randomized, replicated strip trial. Farmers compare practices side-by-side in their own fields, with their own equipment, under their own management.

“It’s the farmers asking questions and using this tool to put those questions to the test on their own farms,” Gailans emphasizes. “We truly believe in farmer-led research.”

Over the past decade, more than two-thirds of PFI trials have focused on cover crops — learning which species work best with corn and soybeans, optimal termination timing, and determining economic returns.

The organization publishes detailed research reports using farmer voices while adhering to scientific standards in the process.

From Curiosity to Confidence

For Jon Bakehouse, who farms 600 acres of no-till corn and soybeans in southwest Iowa’s rolling hills, on-farm research has satisfied a lifelong itch.

“Growing up, we’d try something new on the farm and then move on to the next thing,” Bakehouse recalls. “What drove me nuts was we never quantified what we’d done. I wanted meaningful data on paper.”

That desire for quantification led Bakehouse to field test cereal rye termination timing — a trial he says fundamentally changed his farming operation. He discovered that terminating the cereal rye at soft dough stage rather than pollination produced better kill and rolled flatter, enabling him to eliminate the first herbicide pass in soybeans.

“There’s no better feeling than when you go out and roll crimp on a large scale and it works,” Bakehouse says.

But he is also candid about the challenges: “Every year I want to quit cereal rye because something seems like it’s going to go wrong. But then you talk to Sam or Stefan, and they’re like, ‘Hold on, remember when?’ It’s good to have that tether to success rather than the fear.”

ROI Meets Soil Health

Bennett emphasizes that return on investment drives most farmer research questions, but the benefits extend beyond the balance sheet.

“Does this product pay? Does it do what the salesman claims?” Bennett says. “Those are the simple questions and the fun ones to answer.”

His nitrogen rate trial — part of a coordinated effort involving 40 Iowa farmers — revealed his operation was applying far too much nitrogen. The discovery allowed him to cut back on N, improving both his bottom line and water quality.

“After 150 years of growing corn here, you’d think we’d have had that figured out,” Bennett notes. “But it’s dynamic and more important than ever with the water quality issues we’re dealing with.”

Using the data provided by the farmers, PFI took the lowest and highest farmer reported prices for the N source they adjusted to create two rate treatments, and the lowest and highest reported prices received for corn; these values were used to construct the price scenarios in Table 1 below.

Practical Farmers of Iowa Nitrogen Trials
This is a snapshot of information pulled from the article, Can We Reduce N Rates to Corn and Improve ROI? written by Roberta Bianchin Rebesquini, available at www.practicalfarmers.org
(Practical Farmers of Iowa)

The Science of Staying Honest

Both farmers stress the importance of rigorous trial design, even when it’s tempting to cut corners.

“The random, replicated design keeps you honest,” Bakehouse says. “It helps you stay in the mindset that we really need accurate, unbiased data, regardless of what the results might be.”

Bennett agrees, noting that skepticism about on-farm research is real: “When you have that professionally designed, scientifically established trial, it really helps with our credibility.”

Some of the key design principles both farmers follow include:

  • Long, straight rows on a variety of soil quality
  • Long enough strips for evaluation
  • Multiple randomized replications.
  • Detailed record-keeping throughout the season
  • Statistical analysis of results

The farmers also emphasize starting with manageable trials. “Start small enough that even if something is a total train wreck, it’s not what I lose sleep over is important” Bennett says.

Building Community Through Transparency

Perhaps the most powerful aspect of farmer-led research is the willingness of the growers to share failures alongside successes.

“Being willing to share your failures builds credibility,” Bennett says. “That’s really where the good questions come from for future years.”

Bakehouse described the relief of finding his “tribe” at PFI: “It was like, ‘Oh thank God, other people are messing up and failing too,’” he laughs.

The visibility of field-scale trials on Bakehouse and Bennett’s farm also sparks neighborhood conversations — sometimes uncomfortable ones.

“When I really started pushing boundaries, letting cereal rye grow without terminating it, that interaction kind of ceased,” Bakehouse says. “It became more like, ‘What are you doing again?’”

But persistence pays off. His herbicide applicator recently called to tell Bakehouse his fields showed the best weed control of the thousands of acres he’d sprayed that year — even without tillage or early-season herbicide use.

The Farmer’s Scientific Method

When asked how farmers without established networks can start conducting research effectively, Bakehouse offered some straightforward advice: “Review the scientific method. It’s a simple thing, but such a powerful tool.”

The basics remain constant:

  1. Ask yourself a specific, answerable question.
  2. Design a test that isolates variables.
  3. Collect accurate data.
  4. Analyze results honestly.
  5. Share your findings and formulate new questions.

Bennett adds practical considerations he believes are important: “Can you manage this with your existing equipment and labor?” he asks. “Can you make the split and collect the data without it being too time-consuming?”

Creating Answers For The Future

Both farmers say they will continue running multiple trials this next year, building on previous findings and exploring new questions. Their work contributes to a growing body of farmer-generated knowledge that’s accessible, practical, and rooted in real-world conditions.

“We’re not giving instructions to others,” Gailans says, quoting a PFI farmer cooperator. “We’re sharing how we came to our own conclusions, teaching others to evaluate things for themselves so they can answer: Is this for me or not?”

Learn more about the research PFI and farmer cooperators are conducting at practicalfarmers.org/

AgWeb-Logo crop
Related Stories
DuWayne Bosse of Bolt Marketing says the grain market is seeing pressure from the higher dollar, December option expiration and nervousness about the meeting between President Trump and Xi.
Mike Zuzolo of Global Commodity Analytics says wheat added risk premium, while corn and soybeans saw nervousness ahead of the Trump, Xi meeting.
That’s the question David Hula and Randy Dowdy are asking themselves. They share some of the tactics they’re testing to capture corn yield potential that’s already in their fields.
Read Next
“As bad as it is right now,” says producer Tim Gomes, “this whole theft situation in agriculture is about to get crazier and crazier.”
Get News Daily
Get Market Alerts
Get News & Markets App