Editor’s Note: This article is part of the Drovers 2024 State of the Beef Industry report, which includes an exclusive survey of cattle producers and their thoughts on numerous topics of importance to the future of their operations. To download the full report, click here.
America’s beef cattle inventory continues to tighten, pushing market prices to record levels. Under normal conditions, that would lead to anticipation about building herds again. If this were a typical cattle cycle, the elements for expansion — ample forage and record-high cattle prices — would be in place. However, the current cattle cycle is not typical other than the recent liquidation when drought forced significant culling and resulted in the smallest U.S. cattle herd inventory in 70 years.
The pace of expansion or herd rebuilding in the current cattle cycle will be much slower than past cycles, and the extent of herd building will also be reduced. That has been the case for previous beef inventory expansions since 1975’s peak of 132 million head as subsequent cycles have all peaked below the previous cyclical peak. For instance, the 1982 peak was 115 million head, 1996 at 104 million, 2007 at 97 million and 2019 at 95 million. What has changed?
Production-wise, efficiency has increased and the industry produces significantly more beef with fewer cattle, which impacts prices. When expansion begins, smaller increases in inventory pull prices lower. But there are other crucial factors that influence individual ranchers’ plans to continue in the cattle business.
Volatility Will Increase
The age of farmers and ranchers is critical as decisions are made going forward. Closely tied to age is the financial stress of the market over the previous four years. This plays a greater role for part-time cattle producers. The drought coupled with low prices and accelerating costs of production are key to the decision. I often hear ranchers comment: “Why would I or my spouse continue working in town to support cows that are draining our bank account?”
For many of those part-time cattle producers, the cows went to the sale yard. Will they be replaced? Only time will tell, but many will not return to the business. The other major consideration of this cycle is the price of replacement cows or heifers.
Ranchers are rightfully wary of a market that could become increasingly volatile. It’s a major risk to invest in cows or breed heifers with high maintenance costs that won’t deliver a marketable product for two-plus years.
The decision to own cattle or expand an existing herd will be influenced by high interest rates and rising production costs, further slowing the speed of any herd rebuilding.
Rebuilding The Cowherd Remains On Hold
One of the biggest factors on everyone’s mind revolves around if and when cow-calf producers might begin rebuilding the cowherd. Much of that decision to date has been contingent on the weather. However, despite improving forage availability and conditions (and higher prices), producers remain tepid about running more cows.
The 2024 Drovers State of the Beef Industry survey asked, “What are your plans to restock your cowherd (as a result of the drought)?”
In both 2023 and 2024, 21% of respondents indicated “next year.” The process remains on hold. However, some of that reluctance might prove to be permanent. One key difference in this year’s survey has more producers indicating they have “no plans to restock” (23% versus 14% in 2024 and 2023, respectively).
There’s not much appetite to aggressively rebuild the cowherd. Producers are cautious when it comes to running more cows.
Your Next Read: A Glimpse Into the Cattle Inventory Black Hole
