Grains Lower a Second Week: What Drove the Selling and Are the Lows Close?

Allison Thompson with The Money Farm says the grain market selloff was tied to several geopolitical and macro market factors. However, she hopes a low is close.

Soybeans ended higher Friday with corn and wheat lower and cattle mixed.

Soybeans Rally With Meal Friday
Jan soybeans ended 13 1/4 cents higher on Friday with some technical buying and with help from a $8.70 rally in soybean meal.

Allison Thompson with The Money Farm says meal was supported by meal/oil spread unwinding but also USDA report a flash sale of 100,000 metric tons of meal was sold to Spain. That helped to lift the soybeans for the day.

But.....Soybeans Lower for the Week With the Real
The soybeans were still down nearly 11 cents for the week reacting to the U.S. dollar index hitting 20-month highs while the Brazilian real fell to new lows for the move and is down nearly 16% since Brazil’s presidential election.

“So when the Brazilian real depreciates and the dollar goes up, they’re able to get more dollars for their beans. So it has pushed some producers there to make some sales.”

This becomes even more critical in December through February she says, because the competition between the U.S. and Brazil really starts to shift.

“We are looking at December out of the ports in the Gulf, U.S. beans are still to about 20, 24 cents cheaper than going out of Brazil. But when you get to February, they’re $1.19 under us. So there is going to be some competition here starting to grow,” she explains.

The crop was planted early in parts of Brazil, with the Mato Grosso area getting into harvest even before Christmas. That means the U.S. only has a few weeks to sell soybeans before the U.S. starts losing its advantage.

South American Weather Benign
Adding to the pressure for the soybean market is the fact that there has been no threatening weather yet in South America.

Thompson says, “No, it’s really been a non-event. And usually as we get closer to December, we do start hearing a little bit more about their weather and how things are shifting but we haven’t really heard too much.”

However, it is still early and there is a chance for weather problems to pop up especially as Brazil plants the second crop corn.

Soybean Technical Action
January soybeans were able to close back above the 200-day moving average on Friday, which was important technically as it keeps the funds from liquidating longs.

However, Thompson also looked back at longer range charts. “I’ve been just looking at that January contract for the year. We actually put the low in in January at about $10.66. If you can believe that on January beans and we’ve ran it all the way up to $12.87. This week we held the 50% retracement of that, which comes in around $12.10.”

She says holding that area is a win especially with the selloff in corn and wheat this week.

Trump Xi Meeting Disappoints
All the grains were lower for the week with some disappointment about the Trump Xi Meeting in China on the sidelines of the APEC Summit.

President Trump urged China to buy more ag goods from the U.S. but there was no talk about lowering the 10% reciprocal tariffs or the when China was going to buy the pro-rated $17 billion of non-soybean ag goods they’ve promised.

“Getting something demand driven in this market is going to be key to turning it around,” she states.

Strong Dollar Hurts Corn and Wheat
That is why the strong dollar also hurt the corn and wheat markets this week. Funds were liquidating positions in the ag markets in general but it also extended out to other commodities.

“It expanded well beyond our grains but commodities in general really kind of suffered with the dollar going higher this week. It has an impact on hard commodities and soft commodities. So we saw a really big sell-off in both gold and silver this week,” she adds.

When the dollar goes up to other currencies countries have to pay more for U.S. commodities.

“So we are seeing shifting of the funds and other players in the market moving away from these commodities just because the dollar is high. So not saying it’s going to last forever, but obviously we’re just kind of waiting and seeing where they’re going to go next.”

Stock Market Melt Down Spills Over
The stock market also some massive liquidation this week and that money flow also had an impact on the ag markets.

It also creates some risk aversion and economic concerns for the broader markets which spills over to the agricultural sector.

“Copper this week sold off too. And copper is more of an industrial manufacturing commodity. And to see that sell off too, obviously tells us that there is some economic issues out there that are concerning the market.”

December Option Expiration
Liquidation in corn and wheat this week and even last week was also tied to expiration of December options as funds need to roll or exit those positions and so do farmers. So they were both selling at times.

Thompson thinks that liquidation may be nearly done but there is also some exodus from December futures going into first notice day on November 30.

“We are already starting to see some of those rolls or, getting out of those positions. It is happening earlier this time than a normal month during the year due to the holiday,” she says.

So she is hopeful that liquidation is nearly complete.

What Bottoms the Grain Markets?
After the friendly November WASDE report, Thompson says there was hope that the grain markets had bottomed but new lows were made this week in both corn and wheat.

So are the lows close?

Thompson replies, “Well, I’d like to think that we were getting close. But then you saw the action we got this week. We took out the lows on corn. We made new lows on wheat. And we’re getting down to some key retracement levels and also some moving averages on the bean side. So we really haven’t confirmed anything.”

So what will it take to forge a low?

Thompson says a weather problem in South America is one catalyst, the other is demand. Plus, with lighter trade volume during the holidays she says technicals can sometimes trigger a rally. “So going forward, especially around the holidays, those can be easy targets for the market to go to.”

And with the funds already short in corn and wheat those technicals can spur a short covering rally.

Spring Wheat the Bright Spot
One of the few markets that was higher for the week was hard red spring wheat. Thompson says it did not make new lows like Chicago and Kansas City wheat did either.

She says there is a story developing with spring wheat with some quality concerns in the northern U.S. and Canada. “A lot of that has to do with some quality issues further north. And maybe, hopefully, we’re seeing that this is some demand behind the market.”

Cattle Also Hold Up
The cattle market also held up well considering the melt down in the outside markets which Thompson says is encouraging and tells here that the fundamentals did not change.

“It’s good to see that it was maybe trading some of its own fundamentals, because nothing there has dramatically changed either,” she adds.

She admits the market was anticipating a bullish Cattle on Feed Report and there were also some improved cash bids to end the week which also provided some staying power.

AgWeb-Logo crop
Related Stories
Kernel counts looked promising in Tim Burrack’s corn, but final yields fell below his expectations. He believes sunlight was the missing ingredient his crop needed.
The Crop Protection Network is offering a free online guide to help you take the guesswork out of treatment decisions in row crops.
Scott Varilek of Kooima Kooima Varilek says ideas of higher cash trade may be driving the futures as bids have started to improve at the end of the week.
Read Next
High costs and tight margins mean another tough year. The October Ag Economists Monthly Monitor warns of a growing gap between financially strong farms and those lacking resources to survive the prolonged downturn.
Get News Daily
Get Market Alerts
Get News & Markets App