Will South American Yields Be As Bad As Predicted?

This article discusses why the recent bean rally is happening and how South American yield uncertainty is contributing to it.

Jon Scheve
Jon Scheve
(Marketing Against The Grain)

Missed a recent article by Jon Scheve? Get it sent to you directly every week. Send a request by email: jon@superiorfeed.com

Market Commentary for 2/4/22

Bean Outlook

Everyone wants to know how bad the South American bean yields will be. Unfortunately, it is extremely difficult to predict upcoming bean yields there accurately. Even in the US, most farmers I know are unwilling to estimate their bean yields before the combine is in the field, let alone a month or two before.

The bean rally over the last few weeks is mostly due to persistent dry weather in the southern third of Brazil and much of Paraguay, which usually produces about 10% the size of Brazil’s crop. While crops in both of those countries have suffered, the extent of yield reductions is still uncertain. Last summer predictions ran wild on how bad US bean yields in the northwest soybean belt would be. In the end, farmers in those areas were surprised their yields were not as badly affected as originally feared. Similarly, it seems just too early to estimate final bean yields with any accuracy in South America right now.

Argentina’s beans have more growing season ahead of them, so weather there could still have a big effect on final yields.

This leaves the US bean supply as the global “bean back up” plan. If everyone else runs out, US beans become much more valuable. At the end of the day, it will come down to weather and if someone could predict weather long-term accurately, they could predict future prices too.

If South America’s crop continues to be reduced, US bean prices will increase. If this happens it potentially could cause an acreage battle with corn in the spring.

Corn Outlook

Corn prices appear to have stalled temporarily. Ethanol stocks are extremely high, and profits at those plants have dropped significantly on the recent rally. Plus, rail tank car logistical issues are slowing movement of finished product too. For prices to rally higher, dry weather in Argentina later this month will be needed to help push export demand back to the US.

Market Action

On January 25th, an open order to sell March corn futures at $6.25 I had in place was hit. The order was on 10% of my 2021 production. I am now 60% sold on my old crop corn.

Want to read more by Jon Scheve? Check out recent articles:

Setting Bean Basis At The Highest Level Of the Year

How A Range-Bound Market Left Me With A Sale Above The Current Market Value

Will Beans Find Their Way To $14 Or Will They Trade Back Under $13 Again?

Why “Free” Storage Isn’t Really Free And Actually Hurts All Farmers

Are These Recent Rallies A Christmas Present Or Are They Sustainable Long Term?

Why Futures & Basis Should Be Marketed Separately. Futures May Hit $6 While Basis Could Increase 20-40 cents.

Jon Scheve

Superior Feed Ingredients, LLC
jon@superiorfeed.com

AgWeb-Logo crop
Related Stories
All eyes were on final yields and production, and USDA delivered with record corn numbers. The agency left soybean yields basically unchanged from the November report but did raise overall production.
Will 2026 be a repeat of 2016? Chris Barron, Ag View Solutions, shares four strategies to help farmers capture some profit in this down cycle.
Jon Scheve discusses what is impacting bean prices right now and provides the detail and rationale of a recent trade he did that sold 100% of his soybeans.
Read Next
As the Strait closure enters its tenth week, supply chain gridlock and policy hurdles suggest high input costs will persist through the 2027 planting season, according to Josh Linville, vice president of fertilizer with StoneX.
Get News Daily
Get Market Alerts
Get News & Markets App